Walking around in Circles

A little while ago internet giant Google launched their own social network service to compete with major player Facebook called Google+. Most people asked the question: “Is there really room for another social network?” Besides that, how could Google improve on what Facebook was doing a very good job at already? My first thought was that Google really had to innovate to win over the social media lovers. And if anyone is up to that task, it’s Google.

However, the first thing that immediately set me back is the fact that Google+ at the time of writing still is in beta. That means if you want to sign up for the service, you’ll have to receive an invitation from someone else. So I did some asking around on Facebook (irony?) and a little later my Google+ adventure was about to begin. Now, I am speaking for myself when I say that I feel Google is not known for their aesthetics. Most of their sites are very functional but not very pleasing to the eye. It’s sad to say the same holds true for the Google+ site. I guess function goes before form at Google headquarters.

At first glance, everything is conveniently arranged. The layout instantly reminds of Facebook, which is obviously tried and tested. The thing that sticks out and what really sets aside Google+ is the Circles function. Contacts can be added to Circles; the default Circles include the obvious friends, acquaintances and family. Through the Circles you can choose what you see and what you share with whom. My distribution of contacts among the Circles would probably be mostly among the default ones, if I had more than five contacts available while I’m writing this. Although for some other people this can certainly be a convenient function, for me this doesn’t have a whole lot of added value. Most of the people I add on a social network are friends, so they would all go into one circle. I haven’t got much to hide from most of my contacts, and if I did I would probably just block them, or not accept their request in the first place.

I don’t think Google+ has got what it takes to overtake Facebook as the most used social network. Everything Google+ does, Facebook does better. The Circles function, which was probably the biggest and best innovation on the social network services already available, has been shamelessly copied by Facebook. They recently implemented the function to create lists of contacts, similar to the Circles found in Google+. So the only thing Google+ had on Facebook, is now on Facebook as well. I will certainly keep an eye on Google+, but right now I don’t believe this will be a great hit.


4 Comments on “Walking around in Circles”

  1. IRGIORGIO says:

    Well said. Facebook just needs to further implement the lists-function, cause of right now its a bit hidden. I dont believe in Google +, I think its a waste of time and effort. There is only room for 1 profile page imo!

    • henkdegraaf90 says:

      Have to say i agree there IRGIORGIO. I don’t think Facebook and Google+ will be able to peacefully co-exist. And since Facebook was here first, tough luck for Google+.

      • IRGIORGIO says:

        Facebook added another option for the lists last week I think. It tried to automatically arrange my friends into lists. Its obvious that Facebook tries to implement the same fuction but is still struggling with it, but it wont take long before they get it right. But like you said, if anyone is up for it, its Google

  2. Very nice blogpost Henk! I really like your style of writing as it is informative, get’s to the point but is still very pleasant to read. I also like from which point of view you approached Google+ (aesthetics, comparison with Facebook). I hadn’t thought about the aesthetics myself, but now that you mentioned it, I noticed it too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s